Close Menu
Boston Sports News
    What's Hot

    2027 US Gymnastics Championships set to be held in Tampa

    November 22, 2026

    Boston College fends off UMass comeback in 72-65 battle – Massachusetts Daily Collegian

    November 22, 2026

    Red Sox Had Interest In Corey Seager, CJ Abrams At Trade Deadline

    November 22, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • 2027 US Gymnastics Championships set to be held in Tampa
    • Boston College fends off UMass comeback in 72-65 battle – Massachusetts Daily Collegian
    • Red Sox Had Interest In Corey Seager, CJ Abrams At Trade Deadline
    • The Senate just voted to overhaul college sports. Here’s how – Deseret News
    • How ancient nomadic survival skills became global sporting events
    • How to Watch, Listen and Series History
    • Former No Name Restaurant to become marine robotics hub
    • Netflix, Amazon and Fox Are Chasing the 2030 World Cup as ESPN, NBC and Others Pass on FIFA’s Billion-Dollar Deal
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Boston Sports News
    Sunday, November 22
    • Home
    • Boston Sports News
    • Boston Area Colleges News
    • Boston High School Sports
    • Massachusetts Charity Games
    • All Massachusetts News
    • US Sports News
    • World Sports News
    Boston Sports News
    Home»All Massachusetts News»Massachusetts’ highest court will weigh the authority of local boards in Pittsfield cell tower case. It could result in a statewide precedent | Local News
    All Massachusetts News

    Massachusetts’ highest court will weigh the authority of local boards in Pittsfield cell tower case. It could result in a statewide precedent | Local News

    BostonSportsNewsBy BostonSportsNewsSeptember 16, 2025No Comments5 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Massachusetts’ highest court will weigh the authority of local boards in Pittsfield cell tower case. It could result in a statewide precedent | Local News
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

    BOSTON — The state’s highest court will weigh whether local boards have the authority to rein in cell towers. 

    At issue is a 115-foot Verizon tower off South Street in Pittsfield. Since it went live in 2020, neighbors have said they’ve suffered headaches, nausea, sleep problems and other negative health impacts attributed to the radio frequency emissions.

    The Pittsfield Board of Health issued an emergency cease-and-desist order against Verizon after investigating residents’ complaints. The order called the tower a “public nuisance” that was a “cause of sickness,” the first order of its kind in the country, according to ProPublica. But the board rescinded the order weeks later, after Verizon filed a federal lawsuit arguing the move was preempted by the Telecommunications Act of 1996.


    How the FCC shields cellphone companies from safety concerns

    The residents sued, arguing that the board capitulated and abandoned its duty to protect public health in the Shacktown neighborhood.

    Last fall, the late Judge Francis Flannery ruled that federal law left no room for local regulation provided a tower is operating within Federal Communications Commission standards. The residents appealed.

    The Supreme Judicial Court has now decided to hear the case. At the center of the case is whether the Telecommunications Act preempts “state or local regulation of a wireless cell phone tower in connection with radio frequency emissions from the tower.”

    In their filings, the Shacktown residents argue that boards of health have long been empowered under state law to protect the public from hazards, like contaminated water, noxious industries or other environmental threats.

    That authority, they say, includes responding to the harms linked to wireless facilities, particularly when residents report injuries that, in their view, the FCC has refused to account for. 

    According to the ProPublica report, a growing body of research has raised concerns that radiation from phones and towers may cause harmful biological effects at levels below the FCC’s 1996 limits, even as U.S. regulators and industry say the risks aren’t proven.

    Scott McCollough, an attorney for the neighbors, said the Pittsfield Board of Health itself concluded that emissions from the cell tower were causing injuries to the neighbors, even though the tower is operating below allowable limits.

    But the FCC, which McCollough described as a captured industry beholden to the interests of the same corporations it is tasked with regulating, is refusing to revisit emission standards. And in the meantime, the Pittsfield Board of Health says it is powerless to order the tower offline. 

    McCollough says that this forces residents to move away. He argues that state law requires municipal health boards to protect the health and well-being of residents, and that there should be no exception when the source of the nuisance is a cell tower.


    Pittsfield cell tower opponents have found an ally in the Massachusetts Association of Health Boards

    “In this business and in this world of politics and laws and legal fights, we quite often lose track of the human lives that are involved … these are not rich people, these are just regular folks who were in their homes during COVID and all of a sudden they got deathly ill, and their children did too,” he said. “That’s been the most frustrating to me, getting the court to understand that you’re talking about somebody’s lives.”

    Attorneys for the Board of Health said that the law is clear, and that only the FCC can regulate health impacts of cell tower emissions. Attorney Buffy D. Lord said the city isn’t disputing reports from the residents about their health, but that their hands are tied, so it cannot order Verizon to take the tower offline. 

    “I just feel terrible because, from my point of view, the law is very clear. It’s preempted,” said Lord one of three lawyers from Donovan O’Connor & Dodig, a firm representing the Pittsfield Board of Health. “I’m not at all saying that we don’t believe them, I’m saying we’re not the right place.”

    “We believe the Board of Health does not have the power to regulate the tower” if it’s in compliance with zoning and FCC regulations, echoed Pittsfield City Solicitor Devon Grierson. 

    In a Board of Health brief, Lord and the city’s legal team also warned that allowing local intervention would create a patchwork of standards that undermines the uniform national framework for telecommunications infrastructure that Congress envisioned.

    The case has drawn attention beyond Pittsfield. The justices have solicited friend-of-the-court briefs, and lawyers involved in the appeal said they expect justices to issue a ruling that could result in a statewide precedent.

    The plaintiffs in this case are Courtney Gilardi, Charlie Herzig, Judy Herzig, Mark Markham, Angelika Markham and Elaine Ireland, and McCollough said they are among a group of at least 17 neighbors who say that the cell tower has been making them ill. 


    Cell tower opponents say city attorneys have a conflict of interest. And they want a judge to rule in their favor against Verizon

    Gilardi disagrees with the city’s assessment and said the “move to the Supreme Judicial Court does signal that these issues will be seriously and fairly considered and resolved,” which the plaintiffs are grateful for.

    She said the city solicitor and outside counsel advising the board had a conflict of interest, since Donovan O’Connor & Dodig is also represented Verizon and other wireless companies in permitting new towers, including one proposed at Canyon Ranch in Lenox. In a written statement, Gilardi said the arrangement “explains why the law firm threw the Board of Health under the bus,” accusing the attorneys of prioritizing corporate clients over residents’ health.

    authority boards case cell court highest local Massachusetts News Pittsfield precedent result statewide tower weigh
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleIn Portland, we don’t get Red Sox top prospects for long
    Next Article U.S. men’s national soccer team at a crossroads as World Cup nears
    BostonSportsNews
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Boston College News

    Boston College fends off UMass comeback in 72-65 battle – Massachusetts Daily Collegian

    By BostonSportsNewsNovember 22, 2026
    US Sports News

    The Senate just voted to overhaul college sports. Here’s how – Deseret News

    By BostonSportsNewsNovember 21, 2026
    All Massachusetts News

    MTA Sues Massachusetts Over Political Fundraising Ban

    By BostonSportsNewsNovember 20, 2026
    All Massachusetts News

    MA Cannabis Commission Targets Intoxicating Hemp Oversight

    By BostonSportsNewsNovember 20, 2026
    All Massachusetts News

    Massachusetts House District 7 Midterm Election 2026: Live Results

    By BostonSportsNewsNovember 19, 2026
    All Massachusetts News

    Massachusetts House District 4 Midterm Election 2026: Live Results

    By BostonSportsNewsNovember 18, 2026
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Don't Miss

    2027 US Gymnastics Championships set to be held in Tampa

    By BostonSportsNewsNovember 22, 2026

    ONLY AVAILABLE FOR SUBSCRIBERSThe Tampa Bay Times e-Newspaper is a digital replica of the printed…

    Boston College fends off UMass comeback in 72-65 battle – Massachusetts Daily Collegian

    November 22, 2026

    Red Sox Had Interest In Corey Seager, CJ Abrams At Trade Deadline

    November 22, 2026

    The Senate just voted to overhaul college sports. Here’s how – Deseret News

    November 21, 2026
    Top Posts

    Luke Murray talks NCAA aspirations with Boston College basketball

    September 21, 2026147 Views

    High school sports shouldn't come with a price tag | Opinion

    August 19, 2026101 Views

    Little League Baseball World Series 2025: Bracket, results, scores, schedule, teams and more

    August 14, 202593 Views

    Hopkinton girls named soccer All-Americans – Boston Herald

    August 12, 202571 Views
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Vimeo

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from SmartMag about art & design.

    About Us

    bostonsportsnews brings fast, focused updates from Boston’s sports scene. From pro teams to local leagues, college matchups to high school games, it covers everything that matters to Boston fans.
    Stay connected with real-time scores, game previews, fan reactions, historic moments, and events across the city.

    Our Gallery
    useful links
    • Donate Now
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    All Rights Reserved By BostonSportsNews

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.